About
Welcome to Lyle's, a cherished dining gem located at 1404 E Morgan Ave, Evansville, IN. Known for its inviting, old-school atmosphere, Lyle's offers more than just food; it’s a vibrant experience filled with live music and local charm.
At the heart of Lyle's menu lies their impressive selection of Strombolis, including the acclaimed Lyleboli. Loaded with a sumptuous mix of meat, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, tomatoes, sauce, and real mozzarella cheese, it’s an irresistible treat. The half version is available for only US$6.50, while the whole weighs in at a satisfying US$13.00.
For pizza lovers, the World Series Pizza serves up small and large sizes, topped with a medley of beef, Italian sausage, and vegetables, all resting under a blanket of real mozzarella and baked to perfection. The 10" version is US$14.50, while the 14" size offers more of that delicious experience.
If you're in the mood for something lighter, Lyle's has you covered with a Crispy Chicken Salad, generously layered with fresh greens and vegetables for US$9.50, or a simple side salad for US$5.50.
Lyle’s is not just about the food; it’s about the experience. Customers rave about the atmosphere, noting it as an authentic honky-tonk with an explosion of local talent on stage. One satisfied patron, Randy Vaughn, states, “The best Stromboli Sandwich within 100 miles.” His sentiment is echoed by many who appreciate not only the cuisine but also the engaging entertainment that fills the space on band nights.
From the glowing reviews of satisfied diners like Courtney Fiessinger, who praised the “amazing service” and “outstanding food,” to the enthusiastic mentions of live music and great vibes, Lyle's is more than a restaurant; it's a gathering spot for friends and community. The bartender, Jade, has garnered admiration for her warm service, creating an environment where everyone feels welcomed.
In essence, Lyle's is a must-visit destination for those seeking delicious food intertwined with memorable entertainment. So whether you’re a local or just passing through Evansville, make sure to swing by, indulge in their culinary offerings, and soak up the lively atmosphere. You won’t regret it!
“ Great old style atmosphere. Great entertainment. And the best Stromboli Sandwich within 100 miles. This definitely a place you need to check out! R. Vaughn Henderson, KY ”
“ We had a BLAST! We're from St. Louis MO area and were in Evansville for me to have surgery. We just so happened to pass Lyle's whole. Looking for a place to get my hair braided and after looking at pics of the food on Google we decided to give it a shot! Absolutely thrilled we did. The had live music (right up our alley), good drinks, great food and jusg a good vibe/energy the whole time we were there No regrets: Food: OUTSTANDING Service: AMAZING (unfortunately didn't catch the bartenders name but we were there 4/10/25) Atmosphere: fantastic! Will be back on one of the days I have to come back to Evansville for a follow up ”
“ I have been playing Lyle’s for over 15 years. It’s a great venue with an awesome staff. Jade does an amazing job with the talent and handling the bar, busy or not. She makes sure everyone has a great time. Love the vibe and definitely the food. Do yourself a favor and stop in especially on band nights. Some really great local talent. I have always been very happy to play there and have been treated with professionalism and courtesy. ”
“ Love hanging out in an authentic,down home honky tonk. Couldn't ask for better service and food. Great drinks. Not a wine & dine . A true BAR. Love the karaoke. Best KJ around. ”
“ A special little place to enjoy talented local musicians while having some great food with great company. Check out the Facebook page for upcoming bands and events. ”
“ Great local place. Read reviews and decided to stop in. Good food and great staff definitely glad I stopped in. Will visit again if I am back in Evansville ”
“ What a great place for fun, good music and great food. ”
“ Excellent pizza with great toppings. You need to try this place. ”